15 Old Fashioned Easter Recipes That Prove Grandma Really Knew Best (2024)

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Read my disclosure policy.

Dust off your grandma’s recipe box and get ready for a nostalgic Easter feast! Forget the trendy foraged-mushroom quiche and artisanal sourdough stuffing – we’re talkin’ good ol’ fashioned comfort food that won’t leave you googling obscure ingredients at 3 am on Easter morning.

15 Old Fashioned Easter Recipes That Prove Grandma Really Knew Best (1)

This year, we’re celebrating the classics – the dishes that have stood the test of time. This list features 15 classic Easter recipes that prove your grandma is good at more than just bridge nights and bingo. We’re bringing back the dishes that fueled epic family gatherings.

Blueberry Cobbler

15 Old Fashioned Easter Recipes That Prove Grandma Really Knew Best (2)

A Blueberry Cobbler brings a classic touch to the Easter table with its flaky biscuit topping and vibrant berry filling. It’s a traditional dessert that fills the kitchen with a delightful berry fragrance reminiscent of the past.
Get the Recipe: Blueberry Cobbler

Peanut Butter Pie

15 Old Fashioned Easter Recipes That Prove Grandma Really Knew Best (3)

This no-bake Peanut Butter Pie combines peanut butter and chocolate in a simple, six-ingredient dessert that recalls the cherished flavors of Easters gone by. It’s a classic favorite that’s easy to assemble for your holiday gathering.
Get the Recipe: Peanut Butter Pie

Amish Cinnamon Bread

15 Old Fashioned Easter Recipes That Prove Grandma Really Knew Best (4)

Amish Cinnamon Bread offers a sweet, cinnamon-infused aroma that’s perfect for a nostalgic Easter treat. This comforting and quick-to-make bread is like a warm embrace from grandma, ideal for sharing with loved ones.
Get the Recipe: Amish Cinnamon Bread

Italian Ricotta Cookies

15 Old Fashioned Easter Recipes That Prove Grandma Really Knew Best (5)

Italian Ricotta Cookies are soft, cake-like, and infused with tradition, making them a treasured addition to any Easter celebration. These cookies embody the sweet nostalgia of family gatherings.
Get the Recipe: Italian Ricotta Cookies

Blueberry Upside Down Cake

15 Old Fashioned Easter Recipes That Prove Grandma Really Knew Best (6)

The Blueberry Upside Down Cake is a moist, berry-packed dessert that evokes memories of summer and past Easters. Its simplicity and classic taste make it a timeless choice for your celebration.
Get the Recipe: Blueberry Upside Down Cake

Watergate Salad

15 Old Fashioned Easter Recipes That Prove Grandma Really Knew Best (7)

Watergate Salad, with its signature pistachio flavor, is a five-ingredient, easy-to-make classic that’s perfect for preparing ahead of Easter. This dessert is a blast from the past that’s sure to be a hit at your feast.
Get the Recipe: Watergate Salad

Magic Bars

15 Old Fashioned Easter Recipes That Prove Grandma Really Knew Best (8)

Magic Bars layer coconut, chocolate chips, and a buttery base for a dessert that’s a sentimental journey to Easters of the past. They’re effortlessly prepared, making them a favorite for reminiscing and enjoyment.
Get the Recipe: Magic Bars

Haystack Cookies

15 Old Fashioned Easter Recipes That Prove Grandma Really Knew Best (9)

Haystack Cookies blend chocolate and peanut butter in a no-bake, four-ingredient dessert that’s a throwback to grandma’s kitchen. These quick and delightful treats are a perfect nod to the retro Easter sweets we cherish.
Get the Recipe: Haystack Cookies

Apple Galette

15 Old Fashioned Easter Recipes That Prove Grandma Really Knew Best (10)

An Apple Galette wraps delicious apples in a flaky pastry for a dessert that’s a tribute to rustic traditions. Paired with ice cream, it’s a comforting, retro dessert that’s fitting for a nostalgic Easter celebration.
Get the Recipe: Apple Galette

Lime Jello Salad

15 Old Fashioned Easter Recipes That Prove Grandma Really Knew Best (11)

Lime Jello Salad is a classic, vibrant dessert that brings a fun and retro flair to your Easter menu. Its refreshing taste is perfect for holiday gatherings or a sunny picnic.
Get the Recipe: Lime Jello Salad

Blueberry Peach Crisp

15 Old Fashioned Easter Recipes That Prove Grandma Really Knew Best (12)

A Blueberry Peach Crisp combines juicy fruit with a buttery oat topping for a dessert that’s a throwback to summer days and family gatherings. It’s a straightforward, flavorful treat that’s perfect for Easter enjoyment.
Get the Recipe: Blueberry Peach Crisp

Swedish Almond Cake

15 Old Fashioned Easter Recipes That Prove Grandma Really Knew Best (13)

Swedish Almond Cake is an effortless, elegant dessert dusted with powdered sugar, reminiscent of Scandinavian heritage. It’s a superb choice for adding a touch of old-world charm to your Easter dessert table.
Get the Recipe: Swedish Almond Cake

Homemade Chocolate Pudding

15 Old Fashioned Easter Recipes That Prove Grandma Really Knew Best (14)

Homemade Chocolate Pudding is a rich, from-scratch dessert that forgoes the instant mix for a deep chocolate flavor. It’s a comforting, retro dessert that’s a genuine treat for Easter, evoking the simple pleasures of childhood.
Get the Recipe: Homemade Chocolate Pudding

Frozen Lemonade Pie

15 Old Fashioned Easter Recipes That Prove Grandma Really Knew Best (15)

Frozen Lemonade Pie is a refreshingly simple, no-bake dessert that takes only five minutes and four ingredients to create. It’s a classic, cool dessert to enjoy after Easter dinner, reminiscent of leisurely, sunny afternoons.
Get the Recipe: Frozen Lemonade Pie

Icebox Cake

15 Old Fashioned Easter Recipes That Prove Grandma Really Knew Best (16)

The classic Icebox Cake, with its layers of graham crackers, berries, and whipped cream, is a no-fuss, no-bake dessert. It’s a perfect choice for a sweet, cooling finish to your Easter meal, bringing back the charm of yesteryear.
Get the Recipe: Icebox Cake

Cherry Salad

15 Old Fashioned Easter Recipes That Prove Grandma Really Knew Best (17)

Cherry Salad is a cool, creamy dessert that’s been a staple at festive gatherings. With just six ingredients, it’s an effortless, retro dessert to add to your Easter spread, offering a sweet respite from the heat.
Get the Recipe: Cherry Salad