Mincemeat Cookies ~ The Old Fashioned Way Recipe by Amos (2024)

Home » Recipes » Mincemeat Cookies ~ The Old Fashioned Way

Pin It

PrintEmail

by Amos Miller

Mincemeat Cookies ~ The Old Fashioned Way Recipe by Amos (4)

The ULTIMATE fruit & nut winter cookie. Easy to make - easier to eat!

Mincemeat Cookies ~ The Old Fashioned Way Recipe by Amos (5)

I use lard - you can use a vegetable shortening...

Mincemeat Cookies ~ The Old Fashioned Way Recipe by Amos (6)

Add delicious mincemeat into the batter...

Mincemeat Cookies ~ The Old Fashioned Way Recipe by Amos (7)

...once the mincemeat is well combined,

Mincemeat Cookies ~ The Old Fashioned Way Recipe by Amos (8)

add the chopped nuts...

Mincemeat Cookies ~ The Old Fashioned Way Recipe by Amos (9)

...combine well, then drop spoonfuls onto parchement paper or a lightly greased cookie sheet.

Mincemeat Cookies ~ The Old Fashioned Way Recipe by Amos (10)

Old Glory & The Flag of Michigan

prev1 of 7nextAdd a photo

click to rate

3 votes | 35613 views

2 reviews | 10 comments

I have always loved mincemeat - pie with vanilla ice cream or cookies and cocoa. This is how we make them, except here I will substitute Borden's Nonesuch Mincemeat, or Robertson's (preferred) in a jar instead of homemade mincemeat. You can substitute your favorite shortening (vegetable works great) while I will use rendered leaf lard.

This is a superb mid-winter cookie, and has lots of nutrition and energy because mincemeat is loaded with minced apples and raisins and great spices. A real treat after skiing, snowmobiling or just hiking through the snowy woods.

Prep time:

Cook time:

Servings: 48

Tags:

Kid FriendlyMincemeat Cookies ~ The Old Fashioned Way Recipe by Amos (12)

Quick and EasyMincemeat Cookies ~ The Old Fashioned Way Recipe by Amos (13)

AmericanMincemeat Cookies ~ The Old Fashioned Way Recipe by Amos (14)

Ingredients

Cost per serving$0.14view details

  • 3-1/4 C all purpose flour (GF works fine in this recipe)
  • 1 C shortening (I use rendered leaf lard - vegetable works fine)
  • 1-1/2 C sugar (I use turbinado)
  • 3 large eggs
  • 1-1/2 C mincemeat
  • 1 C chopped walnuts
  • 1 tsp baking soda
  • 1/2 tsp sea salt

Directions

  1. Pre-heat the oven to 400^
  2. Either lightly grease a couple of cookie sheets or precut sheets of parchment paper to fit the pans (smooth side up)
  3. In a bowl, whisk to combine the flour, salt and baking soda
  4. In a second bowl, cream the shortening, slowly adding the sugar, and beat until the mixture is creamy
  5. Add the 3 eggs, beating to combine well
  6. Add the mincemeat, and combine
  7. Add the chopped nuts, and combine
  8. Slowly add the flour, incorporating with a flex spatula, until all the flour is well incorporated
  9. Using a teaspoon, drop the spoonfuls about 2 inches apart, filling each sheet
  10. Bake for 12 minutes
  11. Cool the cookies down (I like to slide the parchment paper to a rack for 15 or 20 minutes so he cookies can firm up before I rack them to dry a bit)

Toolbox

Add to Menu Planner

Go to Menu Planner

Add the recipe to which day?

Mincemeat Cookies ~ The Old Fashioned Way Recipe by Amos (17) Adding to Planner

Add to Recipe Box

Add Personal Note

Conversion Calculator

Watch Related Videos

Languages

Translate!

Nutrition Facts

Amount Per Serving%DV
Serving Size 23g
Recipe makes 48 servings
Calories104
Calories from Fat4745%
Total Fat5.38g7%
Saturated Fat1.17g5%
Trans Fat1.43g
Cholesterol13mg4%
Sodium55mg2%
Potassium18mg1%
Total Carbs12.88g3%
Dietary Fiber0.3g1%
Sugars6.32g4%
Protein1.43g2%

Detailed view

How is this calculated?

How good does this recipe look to you?

Click to rate it:

Advertisem*nt

Advertisem*nt

Menus and Pairings

Goes Well With: A friend and a cup of hot chocolate

Reviews

  • Reply

    Jed Gibbons

    Mincemeat Cookies ~ The Old Fashioned Way Recipe by Amos (25)December 20, 2011

    These Look great. Would make a wonderful breakfast cookie!...especially at this moment.
    I see rendered "leaf lard", which I have to admit I am not familiar with. I hope to have some time between Christmas and New Years to try them.

    1 reply

  • Reply

    Redneck Mike

    Mincemeat Cookies ~ The Old Fashioned Way Recipe by Amos (27)December 5, 2016

    Love mice meat, will try this very soon. Thx

    Comments

    • Reply

      David

      December 19, 2022

      I'm looking for mincemeat recipe of the old school cuz I like to try new things and want to try the original mincemeat if you could send me one recipe I would be very grateful

      • Reply

        Julia Miller

        June 21, 2017

        Number 6 Nate

        • Reply

          Mary Potter

          November 6, 2012

          This sounds terrific. I love mincemeat and am upset that it is only "acceptable" as pie during the Thanksgiving/Christmas holiday season. With this recipe I will be keeping my love of fruit, nuts, and spices going all year. Thank you.

          • Reply

            Amos Miller

            January 6, 2012

            I will post a home-made recipe for mincemeat.

            • Reply

              Patricia Stagich

              January 6, 2012

              I will look for it! Is the homemade version available on here from you? I'd love to try it homemade as well!

              • Reply

                Amos Miller

                January 6, 2012

                Hi, Patricia - If you can get a big jar of Robertson's (British) mincemeat, you will totally love any pastry or baked treat you incorporate this into. A dollop in the center of a buttery cookie, a pie, tarts, cake - a great, sadly overlooked baker's treat. Please let me know what you end up doing. While there 'used to be' suet and actual bits (mince) of beef or venison in mincemeat, now the product is virtually all a great blend of fruits and spices. UInless, of course, you make your own... and I do have a recipe...

                • Reply

                  Patricia Stagich

                  January 6, 2012

                  I have yet to try mincemeat Amos. These sound delish!

                  1 reply

                • Reply

                  Nate

                  December 20, 2011

                  The recipe doesn't state when or if you add the mincemeat. Am I missing something???

                  1 reply

                Leave a review or comment

                Please Log In or Sign Up to leave a review or comment

                Leave a review

                Advertisem*nt

                Sign Up — Free Membershipit's free!

                Recently featured in
                DailyCandy, Trendhunter, Eater, LaunchSquad, Mashable, KillerStartups & SanJose MercuryNews

                Or connect via:

                Recipes by this chef

                Amos Miller

                Cassopolis MI, MI (United States)

                Joined January 13, 2011

                Professional Chef

                101 recipes

                Follow him

                Mincemeat Cookies ~ The Old Fashioned Way Recipe by Amos (41)

                Mincemeat Cookies ~ The Old Fashioned Way Recipe by Amos (43)

                Mincemeat Cookies ~ The Old Fashioned Way Recipe by Amos (45)

                San Antone Black Bean Salad

                Mincemeat Cookies ~ The Old Fashioned Way Recipe by Amos (47)

                Mincemeat Cookies ~ The Old Fashioned Way Recipe by Amos (49)

                Similar Recipes

                Favorite Oatmeal Date Cookies

                Mincemeat Cookies ~ The Old Fashioned Way Recipe by Amos (51)

                Grandma Stone's Old Fashion Sugar Tea Cookies

                Mincemeat Cookies ~ The Old Fashioned Way Recipe by Amos (53)

                1001 Cinnamon Oatmeal Raisin Cookies

                Mincemeat Cookies ~ The Old Fashioned Way Recipe by Amos (55)

                Old Fashioned Oatmeal Raisin Cookies!!!

                Mincemeat Cookies ~ The Old Fashioned Way Recipe by Amos (57)

                Oatmeal Raisin Chocolate Chip Cookies

                Mincemeat Cookies ~ The Old Fashioned Way Recipe by Amos (59)

                Invite your friends

                Know someone who would make a great member of CookEatShare? Invite them!

                Invite Friends

                Create a Group

                Create your own group to share recipes and discuss them with other chefs!

                Create Your Own Group

                This recipe also found in

                Traditional American Home

                Gluten Free

                What Should I Bring to the Party?

                Desserts

                Foodbuzz Refugees

                Glorious Gluten-Free

                Enriching Your Kid!

                Tips and Helpful hints!

                gluten free/allergy free

                What's for Dessert?!

                Gratefully Gluten Free

                allergen/gluten free recipes

                Cookies Cookies and more Cookies Only Group~

                Hodgepodge

                Mom Said This is the Way Grandma Made It!

                Step Into My Kitchen And Sit a While

                Step into my kitchen,and sit a while

                fresh out of the oven

                fresh from the oven

                Vintage Recipes

                Comfort Food Classics

                Healthy Snacks for Kids

                Facebook Pages

                Recent Searches

                • Chicken mushroom soup stove stuffing
                • Tea fine
                • Cod fish with salsa
                • Green light diet
                • Mayonnaise egg
                • Asian broccoli salad chicken
                • Bread dipping sauces
                • Breaded tilapia sauce
                • Cinnamon bun with cream cheese icing
                • Chicken and andouille sausage jambalaya
                Mincemeat Cookies ~ The Old Fashioned Way Recipe by Amos (2024)

                FAQs

                What is in a jar of ready to use mincemeat? ›

                Ingredients: Water, Corn Syrup, Raisins, Dried Apples, Molasses, Corn Starch Modified, Distilled Vinegar, Dried Orange And Lemon Peel, Salt, Spices, Beef, Fruit Pectin, Natural Flavor.

                What is mincemeat cookies made of? ›

                Cream shortening and sugar until light and fluffy; add egg and beat well. Add mincemeat, mixing well. Combine flour, soda, and salt; mix well, and stir into creamed mixture. Drop by teaspoonfuls onto greased cookie sheets.

                Does mincemeat from a jar need to be cooked? ›

                Versions containing animal fats should be cooked before use but those including butter can be used as they are, perhaps stirred into an ice cream mixture. You could even serve an especially tasty version with whipped or clotted cream as a sumptuous festive topping for warm scones.

                How do you improve jarred mincemeat? ›

                Store-bought mincemeat can contain alcohol, and if it doesn't, here's my tip: add some. It will kick your mince pies up to the next level. Rum or brandy go especially well with the other ingredients.

                What was in original mincemeat? ›

                After knights returning from the Crusades came back with spices in-tow, they became common ingredients of the dish along with minced bits of meat (from a range of animals), suet, apples, sugar, raisins, and molasses. "They were about 30 to 50 percent meat in the late Tudor era," says food historian Annie Gray, Ph.

                Why is Christmas mincemeat called mincemeat? ›

                The "mince" in mincemeat comes from the Middle English mincen, and the Old French mincier both traceable to the Vulgar Latin minutiare, meaning chop finely. The word mincemeat is an adaptation of an earlier term minced meat, meaning finely chopped meat. Meat was also a term for food in general, not only animal flesh.

                Why is it called mincemeat with no meat? ›

                The mincemeat filling we know and love today includes ingredients like finely chopped dried fruits, candied orange, spices, sugar and nuts. Its name dates back to 15th century England when mincemeat would actually contain meat, unlike today's version found in our beloved modern mince pies.

                Does jarred mincemeat have meat in it? ›

                Mincemeat can be produced at home. Commercial preparations, primarily without meat, packaged in jars, foil-lined boxes, or tins, are commonly available.

                What are the ingredients in Robertson's mincemeat? ›

                Ingredients: sugar, apples (26%), vine fruits (26%) (sultanas, raisins, currants), candied mixed peel (4%) (glucose-fructose syrup, orange peel, sugar, lemon peel, citric acid), vegetable suet (palm oil, sunflower oil, rice flour), treacle, acidity regulators (acetic acid, citric acid), mixed spices, citric acid, ...

                Can you eat mincemeat straight from the jar? ›

                Mincemeat is traditionally cooked then cooled whilst stirring so it should be fine to eat "raw". A good one will have lashings of brandy in too so that should kill any nasties.

                What is the difference between mincemeat and minced meat? ›

                Mince is ground or finely chopped meat. Mincemeat, if referring to the mincemeat in pies, is a mixture of finely chopped dried fruit, nuts, sugar, spices and alcohol, sometimes containing minced meat, sometimes not.

                Top Articles
                Latest Posts
                Article information

                Author: Otha Schamberger

                Last Updated:

                Views: 5650

                Rating: 4.4 / 5 (75 voted)

                Reviews: 90% of readers found this page helpful

                Author information

                Name: Otha Schamberger

                Birthday: 1999-08-15

                Address: Suite 490 606 Hammes Ferry, Carterhaven, IL 62290

                Phone: +8557035444877

                Job: Forward IT Agent

                Hobby: Fishing, Flying, Jewelry making, Digital arts, Sand art, Parkour, tabletop games

                Introduction: My name is Otha Schamberger, I am a vast, good, healthy, cheerful, energetic, gorgeous, magnificent person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.